Becky, over at Spec Faith today, has resurrected the idea of a CSFF award.
Drop by and engage her in discussion and offer her your brilliant suggestions. If this is something you want to volunteer for, leave a comment to connect.
It's doable. But it will require folks wanting to do it, then doing it.
I, personally, don't like naming it the Clive Staples. Too person and culture specific. I prefer CS, which gives a nod to the venerable author and apologist, but also stands for "Christian Speculative" and echoes the phrase we've been using for the blog tours: CSFF for Christian Science Fiction and Fantasy.
But you go and chime in.